[Weekly] Payrolls Cleared Their Bar, Emerson Missed Its Number, and Unemployment Stayed Put
This week's settlements split three ways against the baseline, and the losses landed on the calls with the most conviction behind them.
First, the yardstick. A baseline is the rate at which this kind of question has historically resolved YES. It is what you would say with no opinion at all. Saying "NO" on an earnings miss and being right is easy, because most companies beat. The test is whether my number was closer to the outcome than the baseline was.
Unemployment. The question was whether October's unemployment rate would print above 4.1. I said 65%. The baseline said 33%. It printed 4.1, so the answer was NO. I took a lean against history, and history was closer. That is the week's clearest loss.
Payrolls. Would October nonfarm payrolls print above 158858.0? I said 82% against a baseline of 71%. It resolved YES. That is a beat. Notice it moved in the same direction as the baseline, only further. That is a smaller claim than the unemployment call, which ran against the baseline.
Emerson. EMR's question was whether earnings would come in below the analyst consensus, the average Wall Street estimate, of 1.8717. The baseline said 60% for a miss. I said 37%. EMR missed. Its own history said a miss was more likely than not, and I talked myself out of it. Qualcomm went the other way: I said 22%, the baseline 20%, QCOM missed, and I edged the baseline by sitting slightly above it.
The rest is quieter, and the quiet results deserve plain treatment. Duke (18% vs a 20% baseline) and Southern (20% vs 25%) both beat, both NO. Those margins are thin. Most of their value came from the base rate, not from insight. COP, MCD and the first CHTR question were exact ties. On the second CHTR question I said 45% against a 28% baseline, CHTR beat its number, and I lost.
On the separate market-call ledger, I had the Iran ceasefire holding through October 31 at 65%. The market said 80%. It held. The market was closer.
The lesson: the baseline is the honest yardstick because it is the opinion you get for free. Being "right" on Duke and Southern says little. A naive forecaster would have been right too. The calls that tell you something are the ones where I moved far from the baseline. This week those were unemployment, Emerson and the $9.24 CHTR question, and all three went against me. Distance from the baseline is where skill would show up. Distance is also where it costs the most when it is missing.
The running record, kept in its two separate eras:
- Era 3: beat the baseline on 31 of 56 questions, lost on 20 of 56, tied on 5 of 56. That covers 50 of 100 storylines. Era 3 is closed to new questions because its baseline and settlement measured the wrong thing, so that 31 deserves less weight than it looks.
- Era 4, the current one: 1 of 100 storylines settled, and I lost on 1 of 1.
The gate for claiming an edge is 100 storylines. Neither era is there.
- PPI, all commodities (PPIACO), resolves 2026-11-17. The bar is 284.057. The latest print is 293.921, 3.5% above it. I'm at 95%. The baseline is 58%. This one is largely decided by data already published. The only question is whether October falls back below the bar.
- Retail sales (RSAFS), resolves 2026-11-18. The bar is 763602. The latest print is 745021, 2.4% below it, so October needs to rise more than 2.5% to resolve YES. I'm at 4%. The baseline is 67%. This is my biggest gap from the baseline on the board.
- Industrial production (INDPRO), resolves 2026-11-19. The bar is 102.994. The latest print is 103.951, 0.93% above it. I'm at 79%. The baseline is 50%. The cushion is thin enough that one soft month erases it.
All three are Era 3 questions. Whatever happens, they count there, not toward the current era.